LexTechSuite - The Legal Tech Ecosystem


State of Tamil Nadu v/s Indian Cable Company Limited

    Tax Case No. 1431 of 1982 (Revision No. 448 of 1982)
    Decided On, 20 December 1982
    At, High Court of Judicature at Madras
    By, THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE BALASUBRAMANYAN & THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE RATNAM
    K. S. Bakthavatsalam, Advocate.


Judgment Text
BALASUBRAHMANYAN, J.


The assessee claimed in his assessment a sum of Rs. 52, 285.27 which it gave to its distributors as additional discount or rebate, over and above the normal discount. The assessing authority held that the assessee was not entitled to exclude this sum of Rs. 52, 285.27 form the taxable turnover. On appeal, the Tribunal pointed out that the liability of the assessee to pay additional discount or rebate had been contracted under the distribution agreement entered into between the assessee and the distributor and it was not as though the additional discount was allowed subsequently on second thought, nor is there any suggested by the assessing authority that Rs. 52, 285.27 was not, in fact, paid by way of discount. This being so, the Tribunal held that the amount cannot form part of the sale price at which the goods were sold and hence it cannot be included in the turnover much less in the taxable turnover.


The Tribunal's decision is quite right both on the facts and on the application of

Please Login To View The Full Judgment!
the law, especially on the definition of section 2(h) of the Central Sales Tax Act. Hence, the tax case is dismissed.